In the dystopian story “Harrison Bergeron” Kurt Vonnegut
imagines a world in which the innate differences among people are eliminated by
handicapping those with greater talent, strength, grace, beauty, or
intelligence. The effort to equalize will fail because people will see the
heavier weights on ballerina’s ankles, the uglier masks to cover beautiful
faces, and the louder sounds to cloud the thoughts of the highly intelligent
are perceived as markers of grace beauty and intelligence and therefore people will
always perceive difference. When Hazel, a person of perfectly average
intelligence, envies her husband George’s mental handicap radio which makes a
loud noise so he forgets his thoughts every twenty seconds, she does not envy
the irritating noise she envies the intelligence that sets him apart as shown
by the device he must wear. Moreover, the efforts to weigh down the graceful or
strong may fail in the longer term because those who are determined to excel
physically will simply get stronger by wearing weights.
To the
extent that the handicap system succeeds in making announcers with beautiful voices
stutter, or ballet dancers stumble and shuffle the effort to equalize makes
every form of human achievement boring. People only want to watch basketball,
or ballet to marvel at the talent and achievement of those who can do extraordinary
things. To make the extraordinary into the ordinary deprives those of ordinary
abilities of the joy of admiring talent and achievement that they cannot
attain.
“And I wondered if hurdlers ever thought, you know, this
would go faster if we just got rid of the hurdles.”
My title is a quote from Ed Sheeran
And my end quote is from The Fault in Our Starts by John Green